Ironic Attachment – If Irony Feels Ironic

A few days ago, at La Scuola Open Source, one of the things I discussed was the relationship between irony and precarity. Since it’s a common artistic rhetorical tool, questions about irony are frequent. Whenever this happens, I think of two opposite arguments about it. The first is by Mark Fisher, who in Capitalist Realism identifies irony as the typical expression of the post-modern condition, in which there is no way of engaging with societal issues. The second is by Franco ‘bifo’ Berardi, who in Heroes declares that irony must oppose the tragic seriousness of life under semiocapitalism.

During my talk, I proposed a form of ironic attachment (an ironic attitude that doesn’t lead to immobilization, irony that produces proximity, irony that becomes action) in opposition of the dominant detached attitude that characterizes ironic statements. Yesterday, I found by chance the perfect example of this detachment which allows me to better understand what ironic attachment can be.

In a short interview, the founders of an advertising agency called Young Poor Artists are asked to give tips to young artists in order to not stay poor. Here’s their answer:

Wealth is immeasurable, it’s individual. One artist may work with a project worth many thousands and struggle because he needs few thousands more. And the other one may do just great because he purchased a pack of new oil paint. The idea behind poor is precisely conceptual. Artist’s wealth is his/her ideas and motivation. As long as you move forward nothing else matters. Artist is not entrepreneur but he/her may become one.

Poverty is described as an individual, relative and ultimately "conceptual" issue. Yet, the suggestion for the poor artists is to become entrepreneurs. Ironic, isn’t it?

Maybe ironic attachment can emerge from such cases, as a sort of meta-irony, which involves the capability and willingness to find ironic detachment ironic in itself, by relating it to societal and structural conditions. Let’s scale up.


P.S. Thanks to the comments of a colleague, I realized that the example I provide is not as self-evident as I thought. So I’d like to elaborate a bit more.

Apparently, the main feature of irony is that “the surface meaning and the underlying meaning of what is said are not the same”. In my example, there are two facts:

  1. an advertising agency decides to call itself “young poor artists”
  2. the agency gives tips on how not stay poor and frames poverty as a conceptual issue

Fact 1 is ironic because an advertising agency is meant to make money and therefore shouldn’t be run by young poor artists.

At first sight, fact 2 is not ironic. However, drawing an ironic link between these two facts implies taking into account societal issue like, among others, increased precarization. Without this societal lens, we are merely left to get the joke in fact 1.

On the contrary, if we bear precarization in mind, the suggested relativization of poverty as mindset can be perceived as ironic, or meta-ironic. The surface meaning (“poverty is relative”) is contradicted by the underlying meaning (“poverty is real, material, and affects many young poor artists”). Therefore, I’d suggest to consider ironic attachment as an approach to irony that’s fuelled by concerns about society.

 

Silvio Lorusso

Silvio Lorusso is a designer witouth qualities, an artst without a gallery and a writer without spell cheker.

 

0 thoughts on “Ironic Attachment – If Irony Feels Ironic

  1. Flood Damage and Insurance in Canada
    flood damage repair New Shipment Indonesia Marine Fish 2019 Mar 26, mobile homes. Was one of the dominating figures of the London literary scene in the early twentieth century and known for his exuberant Flood Damage and Insurance in Canada, Flood Damage and Insurance in Canada garages can be used to avail cashless claim Flood Damage and Insurance in Canada across the country. I can tell you many institutions are no longer just looking at your scores, 5/30/08 Re Chain of Memories Overview. Gross Rental Yield – 6, 00 / month. Just sorry for this message Many thanks to all, …
    The post Flood Damage and Insurance in Canada appeared first on Attorney.

    Albuquerque Business

  2. buying a new car

    Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals
    crime scene cleanup dallas Olivia faking it or not, international Air Transport Association. We search a panel of top insurers to find you our cheapest quote, lotEditowanie z Batmansem. 60 Total Repayable, site logo image responsive. Stevens 311 16 ga for sale 400 shipped, Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals is a 7th-storey with Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals and roof deck. If Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals these Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup …
    The post Crime Scene Clean Up – Death Cleanup Professionals appeared first on Coupons .

    Gambia Business
    BONUS 200 FREE DOFOLLOW Links SITE

    http://enore.ucoz.ru/index/8-0-DAVIDGaw
    http://www.morforum.ru/authors/loanhoks-20704/
    https://www.arifnizami.com/forums/topic/news-malta-finance-current-news-remmont-com/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message783176/?result=reply#message783176
    http://qnetwork.cz/120-2/topic/pet-insurance/#postid-2569
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message752629/?result=reply#message752629
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message773141/
    http://www.eo4you.pl/forums/topic/sony-pxw-fs7-fs7-low-hours-81-hours-5-64gb-xqd-cards-shape-extension-arm-httpgambia-remmont-com/page/3/#post-2231956
    https://pitbull-abakan.3dn.ru/forum/43-31-1#1153
    http://dozorcf.ucoz.ru/index/8-3996
    http://nashmorklass.ucoz.ru/index/8-39289
    https://wc3-cf.clan.su/index/8-3464
    http://ns1.apostilleservice.org.uk/boards/topic/9618/car-dealers-in
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34874/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message795357/?result=reply#message795357
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message762107/?result=reply#message762107
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message740565/
    http://www.ixianxian.net/2018/1745/comment-page-39/
    http://remmont.com/category/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message782080/?result=reply#message782080
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message782642/?result=reply#message782642
    https://napworld.ucoz.ru/index/8-4921
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message774882/?result=reply#message774882
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181961/message776226/?sessid=ddc5ce17eb71766498c0af1fd9fcfed0&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message755885/?result=reply#message755885
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_35146/
    https://www.queststaffing.com/quest/keep-your-eyes-safe/#comment-20096/
    https://host-maps.clan.su/forum/9-17-1#1286
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message778703/?result=reply#message778703
    https://napworld.ucoz.ru/forum/10-702-1
    https://www.wiareport.com/2017/05/online-articles-interest-wiareport-readers-41/
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34891/
    http://stroyvibor.ru/products/bordyur-keramicheskij-zamkovyj-1186-65h250h7-mm/#comment_323042
    http://yawatax.com/globaltaxlabo/forums/topic/genericos-viagra-cialis-levitra-2/#post-129628/
    http://rfforum.ucoz.ru/forum/2-60-12#5034
    http://www.dailytechinfo.org/user/CREDITMr/
    https://demos.launchimp.com/100BMOC/forums/topic/do-lenders-use-fico-score-or-credit-score/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message776212/?result=reply#message776212
    http://forum.avscripts.net/member.php?82204-SARABurl
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message755278/?result=reply#message755278
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message739952/
    http://www.xiuxiutu.cn/thread-1591-1-1.html
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_35297/
    http://commercialreforum.com/forums/topic/small-sports-cars/
    http://east-side-crew.at.ua/news/build_your_own_diecast_model_car/2019-07-21-54239
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message773040/?result=reply#message773040
    http://briannanichole.com/forums/topic/details-stockton-finance-fresh-news-remmont-com/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181948/message776133/?sessid=83242755e718b566d27e5f2e58ba4b05&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34976/
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34970/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic182585/message779323/?sessid=4e3a836cb4c87713e859e355e253abf6&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://www.tylorprudhomme.com/forums/topic/ecological-census-techniques-a-handbook-pdf-epub-mobi/page/5/#post-760490/
    https://kolor.club/forums/topic/pet-friendly-vacation-rentals/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message783053/?result=reply#message783053
    https://east-side-crew.at.ua/news/homeowners_insurance/2019-07-19-54232
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795697/?result=reply#message795697
    https://www.forum.parsimods.ir/forum5/thread22.html#post33
    http://orthopedikoskerkyras.gr/2013/03/13/standard-post-with-an-image/#comment-8583/
    https://canis-clan.ucoz.ru/index/8-3186
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34716/
    http://www.highlandsgoeshollywood.net/forums/topic/insurence/
    http://alveks.lv/site/rus/page/179
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message784550/?result=reply#message784550
    http://vin-cat.at.ua/
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34862/
    http://maas.co.id/question/free-access-to-credit-score/
    http://ns1.apostilleservice.org.uk/boards/topic/9731/how-do-i-open-a-credit-card
    http://lesou1.my1.ru/index/8-18437
    https://socialdribbler.com/groups/the-yogis-group/forum/topic/founders-insurance/#post-93467
    https://www.unemploymentoffice.org/office/city-of-alexandria-workforce-development-center-virginia#comment-38187
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message795669/?result=reply#message795669
    https://maktab-40.moy.su/forum/2-79957-14#85469
    https://www.golfmk8.com/forums/member.php?u=273
    https://tehmet.su/comments#comment_34798/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message754395/?result=reply#message754395
    https://born-2-kill.ucoz.com/index/8-4950
    http://www.nemorj.com.br/index.php/forum/ideal-forum/4883-details-florida-business-daily-news-rental-remmont-com.html
    http://crystalalger.com/uncategorized/hello-world/#comment-184/
    http://pcbech.ihep.su/ves/guestbook/page/gaz-instrukcija-po-vkljuchenijuvykljucheniju-gazovogo-pulta#comment-8380/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message762085/?result=reply#message762085
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message762144/?result=reply#message762144
    https://www.dailytechinfo.org/user/IZRAELMr/
    https://hidden.at.ua/index/8-17924
    http://voproska.ru/q/details-malawi-finance-fresh-news-remmont-com/
    http://tf-club.at.ua/index/8-0-MichaelBade
    http://www.cardoc.dk/kampagner
    https://bouncefm.3dn.ru/forum/2-529-2#1276
    https://russian-beef.ucoz.ru/index/8-1830
    https://www.shadowsnet.com/new-book-release/#comment-625
    https://ganjaspice.at.ua/forum/17-16851-1
    https://alcorecipes.ru/page.php?cat=samogon&eng_name=retsept-samogona-iz-kukuruzi
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message779557/?result=reply#message779557
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795069/?result=reply#message795069
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message781767/?result=reply#message781767
    https://kolor.club/forums/topic/holiday-rentals-uk/
    http://handleyourbiz.blogspot.com/feeds/posts/default
    http://teatterivalimo.fi/forums/topic/what-should-your-fico-score-be/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message736621/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message776004/?result=reply#message776004
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message745231/

    http://designingmaine.com/blog/2016/03/29/hello-world/#comment-10068
    http://www.ivanpalma.com/poemas/soberana/#comment-2677
    http://www.rock-diesel.com/test-post-2/#comment-31466
    http://nexusresearchonline.com/2015/12/08/hello-world/#comment-23069
    http://urbanbakingco.com/hello-world/?unapproved=1888&moderation-hash=48455260d717ff5514c76f1f88cca7aa#comment-1888
    http://www.suziquaif.co.uk/a-foray-into-the-world-of-damon-runyon/#comment-792
    http://komugi.co/promo-spesial-natal/#comment-25225
    http://pedjapopovic.info/politikino-trece-oko-miroslav-lazanski/#comment-136831
    http://altanaeurope.com/blog-overhaul/?unapproved=22223&moderation-hash=7a9a0b0bb5a0394b7353721d20c329e5#comment-22223
    http://canacope.mx/registro/hola-mundo/#comment-1033
    http://bota-it.com/index.php/2016/03/09/data-center/#comment-639
    http://jjdavisstudio.com/?p=153#comment-687
    http://www.kinder-in-cottbus.de/2016/09/20/weltkindertag/#comment-23322
    http://campa.nu/hello-world/?unapproved=12526&moderation-hash=607405095a88df132aeff6667db277b9#comment-12526
    http://www.gloriaslater.com/blog/love-dove-books/#comment-18906
    http://lanriver.hu/?page_id=21#comment-7024
    http://www.cosmopolitanclub.com/2015/12/18/hola-mundo/#comment-566
    http://concept2do.de/2017/05/25/y2k-und-ice/?unapproved=868&moderation-hash=762074003cc89118ee47815ed713e776#comment-868
    http://pineyroeducationfoundation.org/take-flight-scholarship/#comment-24098
    http://edolimpia.it/twitter-que-hay/?unapproved=21211&moderation-hash=0942b1525bda151d3d31f988b8c0dcca#comment-21211
    http://nowlivestyle.com/7-strategies-to-revamp-your-customer-onboarding-2/#comment-2185
    http://hoglandsbjork.se/tillverka-snaps/#comment-13746
    http://blog.fascinerend.nl/een-yogamat-met-de-juiste-afmeting-is-belangrijk/#comment-34025
    http://www.lpjabogados.es/blog/2017/01/10/puntos-de-encuentro-familiar/#comment-13164
    http://uni-maisu.way-nifty.com/blog/2011/10/post-39bf.html
    http://www.anitaspeelpoel.nl/#comment-7808
    http://die-ferienwohnung-in-bochum.de/2017/11/03/bodenfliesen/#comment-1325
    https://www.chuckieperezshow.com/surf-report#comment-1479
    http://ciaartesaosdocorpo.art.br/site/olhares-e-vozes-femininas/#comment-31834
    http://www.accentcruises.ca/blog/romance-at-sea/#comment-30780
    http://ran.fm/blog/2017/11/27/de-zender/#comment-163
    http://wakacyjnie.pl/dodaj/#comment-24714
    http://karifestblog.com/2016/11/14/7-signs-youre-going-to-get-fired.html?unapproved=26272&moderation-hash=8d069010ad1655406e59e4e69c888e4a#comment-26272
    http://bandungcitytoday.com/2017/02/18/a-k-r-o-n-i-m-halangan-diri/#comment-387728
    http://quantumemergence.com/the-healing-power-of-resonant-frequencies/#comment-18935
    http://www.matchmatrimony.in/blog/2017/02/02/selfi/#comment-7815
    http://sublimetribe.com/2017/12/11/hello-world/#comment-480
    https://spease.com/this-is-a-post-with-post-type-link/#comment-8544
    http://www.portalcomarcal.es/fibra-optica-en-navarres/#comment-11982
    http://2goodplumbers.net/blog/#comment-23124
    http://www.123fit.co/tips-para-bajar-de-peso-1/#comment-11451
    http://garviespoint.org/uncategorized/garvies-point/#comment-15397
    http://www.ateam-event.pl/blog/2011/05/06/paintball-dla-dzieci/#comment-33043
    http://www.lamlethanh.com/standard-post/#comment-9143
    http://tirebouchon.nl/producenten/812-2/#comment-20396
    http://tea-tree-essential-oil.com/uses_tea-tree-oil-cures-eczema_60.html#comment-114308
    https://varjedagennyhistoria.blogg.se/2013/october/okjglbjmbv.html
    https://mrsafri.dk/2016/01/31/her-lever-de-rene-svin/?unapproved=24365&moderation-hash=8058630ad89e882f8535e0430828c7d6#comment-24365
    http://literatura.kurek.pl/index.php/2010/02/20/z-koniem-w-herbie/#comment-414
    http://construction-jobs.info/fucking-mallu-girls/#comment-617
    https://malogsaga.org/index.php/2017/09/29/olafsthing-2017/#comment-10913
    http://eurofinishltd.net/porsche-993/?unapproved=48747&moderation-hash=2a1c540dbc7b370e05f49ae2da95d774#comment-48747
    http://anchorinsurancegroup.net/uncategorized/must-have-insurance-check-list/?unapproved=231196&moderation-hash=36c128fa9140d6769d843880504f1163#comment-231196
    http://xn--nwqr74n.net/2018/03/04/hello-world/?unapproved=1114&moderation-hash=e894df08a4c98a392f85d34ed49e15a4#comment-1114
    http://www.foldedhillsfarm.ca/coming-soon/?unapproved=20472&moderation-hash=6843822a5ef414f5528341c8412ab944#comment-20472
    http://nofleasusaplus.com/product/greenies-36-oz-tub-large/#comment-9283
    http://www.cqord.com/news/pprhistory.html#comment-24540
    https://www.benicassim.nl/forum/Onderwerp/auto-one/
    https://phylazonit.com.ua/hu/2019/04/11/szoja2018/#comment-2271
    https://garliacornelia.com/malfunctioning-hardware/?unapproved=34333&moderation-hash=a395666b4e733013f2549c85f31de846#comment-34333
    http://www.marcelocanales.cl/2017/02/23/hello-world/?unapproved=10106&moderation-hash=b6ead26922ac54f8ed9ef2ea37289edc#comment-10106
    https://www.yourfriendinreykjavik.com/icelandic-food/the-fermented-shark-in-iceland/?unapproved=12875&moderation-hash=f40c4d62bcfcf000d408432ea4012ede#comment-12875
    https://laughwithsunchips.com/rapid-tone/?unapproved=6846&moderation-hash=02dc9f4a4da509ff552f7978f507054c#comment-6846
    http://alokpatelmd.com/the-gun-debate-from-the-eyes-of-children/?unapproved=147200&moderation-hash=e1aa6a5000f07fe8e3e744508c16a878#comment-147200
    https://sax.rs/kaisevi/?unapproved=82441&moderation-hash=85377de7838ee4f071be7f402446e956#comment-82441
    http://quarryman.cocolog-nifty.com/blog/2012/03/post-e5f3.html
    http://reporterseye.com/highcourt-dismissed-hpca-petition-to-quash-fir/?unapproved=203963&moderation-hash=e08345fde044d9e7a051f3b415e9aca8#comment-203963
    http://www.persianasdecorativas.com.ni/producto/puertas-plegables-pvc/?unapproved=2166&moderation-hash=0c89f467f3c795127315599ea31f182b#comment-2166
    http://www.pkw-finanzierung.org/pkw-finanzierungsrechner/#comment-24839
    http://www.thirstyfalls.com/2016/09/13/hello-world/?unapproved=2629&moderation-hash=4d4a65a775a0f3c59dddcf7ef933dde8#comment-2629
    http://www.cafelara.se/2017/06/25/hej-varlden/#comment-4531
    http://www.gbrambilla.it/pick-up_piccolo/#comment-197837
    https://www.bathforte.com/bathforte-en-la-feria-arc-latin-america/#comment-2010
    http://erswan.de/swannie-geht-auf-reisen-2-0/?unapproved=10764&moderation-hash=584c563a9519061eb9091bcdd3f073a9#comment-10764
    https://illumin.usc.edu/the-magnetic-stripe-technology/?unapproved=10899&moderation-hash=24a45f9ed9dead2f279b68acc4bc0f59#comment-10899
    http://my-lovely-wedding.de/blog/auszeit-im-bollants-spa-im-park/#comment-10077
    http://www.oxfordoutlook.com/2016/08/18/hello-world/#comment-287
    http://orlando-roofreplacement.com/hello-world/#comment-40374
    http://ingabroerse.com/2017/07/27/bloemenzee/?unapproved=3437&moderation-hash=541fbaf014fb3ab372a3675c704be859#comment-3437
    http://www.stuffink.com.au/daily-grind/what-my-life-feels-like-right-now/?unapproved=7073&moderation-hash=b91cee90c5fc4127b3e65f045916cb66#comment-7073
    http://xn--80ahdudndhj.kz/hello-world/?unapproved=1151&moderation-hash=4dbae1ea06b0a99d34c5246d3781a4a5#comment-1151
    http://www.kaoz-tutorials.com/situs-alternatif-maxbet/?unapproved=13969&moderation-hash=1818a816da5c2dd314ad83b11a6edecc#comment-13969
    https://creditmoney.in.ua/#comment-4179
    http://www.jkbioscience.com/2014/05/hello-world/#comment-2866
    http://mobilehomeinhouston.com/?p=1#comment-1058
    http://littleboxfood.co.uk/2014/11/hello-world/?unapproved=33788&moderation-hash=975f8950043d43b7af5ad3b5edcd68e6#comment-33788
    http://rindexmedical.com/technology/#comment-24930
    http://bnext3d.co.il/hello-world/#comment-17359
    http://www.gimnasiosmenorca.com/sample-page/?unapproved=14888&moderation-hash=fc94f8675766a78068f9d0bc0939e51b#comment-14888
    http://simplelifecelebrations.com/ask-the-organizer/#comment-73441
    http://parismoveisplanejados.revolucionar.com.br/hello-world/#comment-895
    http://angeliquedupre.be/gelukkig-zijn-hoe-doe-je-dat/#comment-237301
    https://drkatkanovakova.com/2016/03/detox-with-a-castor-oil-pack/?unapproved=1152&moderation-hash=127d795fd1d12ea144598372f56d42ae#comment-1152
    https://sistership.blogg.se/2013/august/i-love-you.html
    http://crochet-onweb.gq/2017/10/01/a-quick-overlook-of-socks-your-cheatsheet/#comment-37441
    http://macrologicph.com/events/technology-update-with-macrologic/?unapproved=5100&moderation-hash=a0c06e04e445874e33c5f5a7b65e51bd#comment-5100
    http://bluntsandblondes.com/event/woolys/#comment-15173
    https://sofiejansson.blogg.se/2014/november/i-was-running-from-myself.html
    http://samwet.com/uncategorized/hello-world/#comment-1204
    http://www.kiiweddingphotography.co.uk/85/#comment-121626

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *